Beware the Red Hat Lady


The mystery shopper wore a red hat.
She wasn’t much of a mystery.
At the bank where I spent a decade leading change, we hired an outside firm to send shoppers into our branches with a checklist. Greet the client by name. Smile. Keep the lobby pleasant. Don’t keep anyone waiting.
Then someone noticed the hat. After that, she’d walk out of one branch, and the phone would already be ringing at the next one. “The mystery shopper is the lady in the red hat.”
Fifty-some branches later, the scores looked fantastic. And those scores didn’t stay in a drawer. They went up the chain, into the reports executives used to judge how we were doing.
The scores measured how our teams performed when they knew they were being watched, not what clients experienced every other day of the week.
Nobody had lied. Every number was real. It just wasn’t true.
The Ticket to the Dance
If you lead change without formal authority, you already know executives want data. They’re weighing your idea against a dozen others competing for the same budget, and numbers help them manage risk and see the trade-offs. Showing up without data can feel like showing up to the dance without a ticket.
So we bring numbers. Survey scores. Dashboards. Shopper reports. Sometimes we bring them because they’re the best we have, and sometimes because they say what we hope they’ll say.
That’s the trap. When you put a number in front of an executive, you’re vouching for it. If it later turns out the number was gamed, irrelevant, or never checked, the damage doesn’t stop with that report. They’ll wonder about the next one, and the one after that.
The Myth of Having the Answer
One of the myths about trust is that it comes from always having the answer.
It doesn’t.
Saying “I don’t know yet” can feel like losing the room. Saying what sounds good, or what will get you a yes, feels safer in the moment. But presenting unverified data as if it were solid is worse than having no data at all. It borrows credibility you haven’t earned, and eventually the loan comes due.
An honest “Here’s what we know, here’s what we don’t, and here’s how we’ll find out” does something a polished dashboard can’t. It tells the executive you care more about the truth than about winning the meeting. In Trust Equation terms, it lowers your self-orientation, and that does more for trust than any chart.
How a Trusted Guide Treats Data
This isn’t a case against mystery shopping. With the right safeguards, a trained, impartial observer still sees things no survey will.
The lesson is broader. Before you put your name on a number, run it through four questions:
Source. Who provided this, and what do they gain from how it looks?
Collection. Did measuring it change the behavior I’m trying to measure?
Analysis. Does it match what the people closest to the work are telling me? If not, the gap is the story.
Reporting. Have I named the limits before someone else does?
None of that requires more data. It requires more candor about what your data can and can’t tell you.
The red hat lady didn’t fool anyone in the branches. Chances are, the only people who didn’t know were the ones reading the report.
Don’t let that be you, or the executives counting on you.
If this was helpful, The Trusted Guide newsletter brings a new idea like this to your inbox each month. Subscribe here.


Comments